2008-10-08

開會地點

大家好,

本月二十五日的讀書會,最終決定於文藻外語學院至善樓十二樓,下午2-5點,可早到!

由劉俊裕及本人準備導讀講義,希望大家都能來, 週六學校沒人,方便停車。
如由高速公路,請由鼎金系統下左營,轉鼎中街不久即至後門;
如果要至前門,則轉至民族路,一段900號,很好找。

如有可能,下回開會,再協調高師大台灣文化與語言研究所所長,借用協調高師大的場地,

如果有人要由台南出發者,我可載四個,搶先報名。

Kind regards,Yu-Hsuan Lee
宇軒

2008-10-01

feedback

各位好,

我和江森聊了我們的第一次讀書會,幾個問題給他,他又很有耐心的回答如下,雖然仍是抽出重點,但已夠豐富,希望稍解大家當日的困惑, 光是這些回應,我們可否進一步討論有無整理出來的可能?

此外,我想計畫,我們明年最後一場後,或許請他出席一次回顧會,做個總結及反思。
Kind regards,Yu-Hsuan Lee 宇軒



From: richard.johnson61@btinternet.comTo: blue95_7399@msn.comSubject: Re: Chapters of the book on BlairismDate: Wed, 1 Oct 2008 11:19:44 +0100

Dear Lee
Thanks for these very interesting questions.It must have been difficult to read the chapter as a freestanding essay. It is from a book about History, Theory and Politics and really needs this larger context.
Replying fully would take a lot of time and perhaps should await my visit, but:

1. Please tell your sociologist that I'm grateful for the appreciative comment. A major reason for writing at the time was an argument about history and theory, in which the two practices were often opposed and the role of abstraction in history-writing was underestimated. Marxism was, in this late 70s/early 80s, debate often the point of reference. For example, many of those writing social history at the time were either ex-communists or influenced by the new left or (like me) influenced by historians like EP Thompson. So it made sense, in this context, to go back to Marx himself - who does have very rich methodological reflections. I wanted show how abstraction and detailed narrative or concrete studies were not opposed practices in Marx's own work, but worked together. Theory was also more than a research question or hypothesis. I have actually found this work useful ever since because it helped me understand about the key continuing issue of theory and the empirical, micro/macro etc. For example, I would criticise some macro-sociologists, certainly Giddens, for failing to bring concrete studies to their theories. His theories are no more than generalised descriptions often inapplicable to particular experiences, places and times. I think Marx would have called them 'thin abstractions'.

2. Please tell your phenomenologist that I am very interested in this comment. Since I wrote this piece, I have become very interested in the work of Hans Georg Gadamer and Paul Ricoeur, especially Ricoeur and in the similarities and differences between these phenomenologists and the cultural circuit as I developed it from Stuart Hall; (and ultimately Marx's Grundrisse). A key point of connection is with Ricoeur's idea of mimesis 1,2 and 3 in Narrative and History. And his idea of refiguration. Really interesting questions are raised about structure and visibility which need time to discuss! In general I have a critical but also appreciative relation to structuralism - a bit like Ricoeur's in fact!

3.Your community worker is spot on about EPThompson and the longer debate in the New Left. Narrowly the piece was a reply to his big attack on Althusser - The Poverty of Theory. A lot of our work on history and theory had Edward Thompson as our main discussant. Unfortunately the discussion got very heated and hurtful and we felt he didn't listen to us, but I continue to relate to him in my work and my life in many ways. For example, I think that my current political involvements are, in part, saying to EPT, yes, my work is political (he said it wasn't!). The piece today has some political relevance I think. It could also be seen to be addressed - on the other side of the argument - against dogmatic or over-abstract theories, which pretend to be actual descriptions, whether coming from sociologists or Marxists or neo-liberal economists! It has to be said that Marx himself sometimes made this mistake - hence 'the Best Marx'
4 The piece is certainly materialist - and I still think of myself as a historical materialist and contemporary historian especially interested in culture. I am happy with Raymond Williams' 'cultural materialism'! But what does this mean???
5 Yes, relations between disciplines. We were trying to work out what a cultural studies approach and use of history writing might be, different from cultural history. I have written about this relation directly elsewhere and could give references if it would be useful. One approach was to studying history-writing itself as a cultural practice = the main concern of the book from which the chapter is taken.. Later in different groups we worked out the idea of Popular Memory as another way of looking at history. In general I would insist that it is not only the discipline of history that should work historically! (My own background is as a historian of course).
Hope this helps.
Did you get the documentation? Was it enough?
cheers
Richard


Dear Richard, We had a successful section of reading group on last Saturday.There will be one section every month before your visit in April 2009.In this first section, I found some interesting questions related to this paper (reading for the best Marx) that might be useful for your reference.I list two main questions as follows.

1. Why did you write this articule? Why do you think it is important to find a best version of Marx?

- As one sociologist was impressed by your use of a lot of example to support your argument, he was humbled by this detailed analysis and said that he can only follow your framework in understanding this articule. But he has no clue the reason why you write this articule.

- As the other art-based scholar argues that the circuit you address involves different moments. He draws on phenomenology and shows his suspicion of the articule based on the circuit, which seems to work within a "structure". But, he wants to know that how you deal with those areas which are both visible and invisible at the same time? (I am not sure if I translate in the correct way!)

2. How does the arguement or hypothesis of the articule emerge? What is the political goal of this articule?
- As one community worker posed these two questions, he was puzzled whether your argument has something to do with the conflict between you and EP Thompson. Is it related to the long-term argument within the new left circle? Did it relate to you earlier reflection within the history discipline?

- One education-based scholar posed a question about the materialist foundation in which the articule was written.

- One cultural studies scholar addressed the tension between disciplines, e.g., cultural studies and sociology, history and cultural studies. So, perhaps it also caused the argument over theory/history/politics relationships emerge?!

Kind regards,Yu-Hsuan Lee

2008-09-27

927之後

各位好,

今天第一次讀書會應該算是個好的開始,謝謝大家都能來,並熱情參與討論,

感謝陳巨擘老師的導讀,清楚之外,也修補了我閱讀經驗的貧乏。相信大家多少有同感。
其次,今天未能與會者,期待你們也能於十月二十五日參加第二次讀書會。目前地點暫訂高雄,細節我再傳閱。

由於下次的文章是What is Cultural Studies Anyway。能否徵求或推薦有志者扮導讀者?可否於一週內向我報名。
導讀費用是一仟六百元,並補助車馬費。


今天的上半場,都有錄音,會請助理整理出來,下半部錄音有誤,可能會以筆記整理為主。

如有任何的需求,請告知。

也請有意於明年四月一同參與江森活動者,告知可能的想法,我們可提早計畫及組織。
Kind regards,
Yu-Hsuan Lee
宇軒

2008-09-13

927

各位好,

九二七當日如開車入成大醫學院停車場,請告知警衛本讀書會於餐廳舉行,應可停車。而時間再提醒一次,2:00至5:00,會後可於餐廳用餐。

而我今天放了一個小短片,是江森兩三年前與我們討論的過程,不論內容談什麼,主要說明他老人家總是精神,大老遠聽學生的問題,耐心地回答
由於檔大,且個人科技能力不好,只能放這剪下來的,品質問題見諒。

另外,也偷渡一下別的事件,寶順(鼎立)工會罷工,有待支持。http://www.coolloud.org.tw/

宇軒

2008-09-08

炎炎秋日,來南部讀書

各位好,

927讀書會時間地點已確認,希望大家第一次都能與會,先認識、熱身一下。

由於本案已申請到國科會的經費,有些補助,如導讀者的講費及差旅、與會者的餐會及影印等,經告知,目前採實報實銷制,我不會經手錢,都將按領據或收據報帳(沒有特別費!)大概兩個月報帳一次,

第一次導讀者是陳巨擘老師,我們會提供單槍供其使用外,也跟他及其他日後可能導讀者說明,請你們要向學校請"公差假"即便是週六,也請向學校人事室請假條,我們才能向國科會請款。請註明差旅經費來源是國科會,經典研讀會。

宇軒

2008-09-05

927讀書會地點確認

各位好,

當天週六下午二時起,請準時到成功大學醫學院四樓的餐廳第二研討室,其在建國校區位於小東路上成大醫院旁。

如果會後有空,大家請留下來用餐。

宇軒

2008-09-01

letters between Richard and me, regarding his visit to Taiwan and our reading group

以下所列的書信體,幫助大家多認識江森,
我將近期和他通信的內容轉貼如下,其實也可由書信內容做分析,
我想接下來讀書會的對話,或許我們也應該整理出來,編成專書或專文?我希望用各種形式來辦江森的活動,大家如果系所也想共襄盛舉,協辦或出人出錢都歡迎!

宇軒

Re: Selections and alternative sources
寄件者: Richard Johnson (http://bl140w.blu140.mail.live.com/mail/ApplicationMain_13.1.0132.0805.aspx?culture=zh-TW&hash=271179879#)
寄件日期:
2008年7月12日 上午 11:18:29
收件者:
Lee Yu-Hsuan (blue95_7399@msn.com)
Dear Lee,
I have just got back from a week's holiday and am away tomorrow and Sunday at the CND Council in London. This is a rather formidable list of questions, of the sort one might expect for a permanent full-time post! However, I do very much appreciate your efforts, Lee and I am still keen to come, and will choose to see this information as part of the dialogue, so when I get back I will try and see if I can find the information and the documents you ask for.
warm wishes
Richard

On 7 Jul 2008, at 07:18, Lee Yu-Hsuan wrote:
Dear Richard,I just consulted a senior scholar who is in charge of the application with respect to your visit. He implies that I need to make your background more explicit for those examiners related to other areas, such as science. So, I perhaps need your good memory to recall your works overseas and their timelines.
For example, I list some questions for you to follow.
1. When did you teach in other countries and make visits to places in US and Europe for intellectual exchanges?
2. Why do you think the best examples as teaching 'Compact Courses' - a week or so long on national identity - in two German Universities - the Humbolt University in Berlin and the Cultural Studies Centre at Tubingen - both famous for this work?
3. What themes did you work with Stanley Aronowitz at the Graduate Centre at City University New York?
4. What is your role in the Erasmus cultural studies circle, a European wide network? Do you have engaged in any similar organisation?
5. What is the main contribution of you and your works during the CCCS life (I know it is a silly question, but I don't know how to make a judgment to be honest)?
6. Also, what is your role during the time at the NTU?
7. Would you be able to talk more about your roles in WEA and other public activities? (I know some are in the CV, but I need to know more about these organisations and your participation).
8. Would you be about to make a long list about any forums (education/social/...) you have been involved? And explain a bit for us?

All these questions are very important for me to revise an introduction of you that related to the funding and further works for mobilisation. As one organiser suggests, we may like to organise a reading group beforehand, and also organise a team to translate those articles and publish that in Chinese. Also, we would like to make the passage of your trip into a video documentary. Thus, there are a lot of issues to be prepared. As for certificates, I wonder if you have any contracts or a letter of appointment, which might be more important than the PhD certificate. Sorry about all these paper work and procedure. If possible, would you please provide these above by the end of July?

Thank you a lot.
Kind regards,Yu-Hsuan Lee


From: blue95_7399@msn.comTo: richard.johnson61@btinternet.comSubject: RE: Selections and alternative sourcesDate: Thu, 3 Jul 2008 00:15:14 +0800
Dear Richard, Nice to have your positive responses. I will try my best to organise some good people to arrange this event and make the agenda more explicit.As for information, if possible, please give me a formal list as you address as follows. At the moment, I put you in a position - chair forum professor - which seems to be kind of "eminent" (whatever) scholars. To be honest, I really have no idea of that title. But it needs evidence to legitimate. So, if there is no evidence, I would change this status into kind of visiting professor. You definitely had many experiences and memories. Would you be able to give me a list recently, including these experiences and memories in detail? I will like to try again and see if the bureaucracy can really see the difference. Anyway, I am looking forward to your coming indeed. And I really admire that you still work so hard to fight against the hegemony.

Once you prepare the certificates or PhD, please let me know. I will tell you how to send to Taiwan.

Sorry, I am not experienced in doing this, so some tedious things emerge at some points.

Kind regards,Yu-Hsuan Lee


From: richard.johnson61@btinternet.comTo: blue95_7399@msn.comSubject: Re: Selections and alternative sourcesDate: Wed, 2 Jul 2008 15:55:27 +0100
Dear Lee,
Thank you for kick-starting once more the discussion about my visit. there is something very interesting in the way you hit on things that really fit and correspond with my thinking. This last month I have been busy working on a paper about city education in Leicester, that amounts to some educational and political changes that focus on the reinvention of a school board - a directly elected single issue local authority for education, to meet the current democratic deficits and form a centre of resistance to central government and the global tendency to privatisation. Also of course I have been working against the current plan to expand the nuclear power industry here which has involved writing to MPs and framing policies for national and regional CND (Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament)
So you van see that your version of the visit fits very easily with my inclinations and perhaps my most recent expertise. Of course, I should need t o know in advance more about the issues in Taiwan.
I am happy with what you suggest. Especially about the resistance to the grand tour, and star like qualities. I am more than happy to remain in the South - which sounds fascinating - and have much more intensive discussions than is usually possible.
I would be happy to do a workshop series on the themes you describe or a series of one-offs with different groups. In fact I love all 4 your questions -they are so much part of my agenda. Perhaps i would rephrase your first a little. It is more a question of what aspects are really useful and how cultural studies can be made to work for local politics. I suppose this involves saying what 'it' is, but there are so many versions and I think my own is quite particular and perhaps it is in tension with dominant ones today, especially in the anglophone academy. This distance increases perhaps as I move away from academic practices and ethos. I don't mean move away from intellectual effort and truth-seeking of course - you know what i mean. So I suppose the first session or section would be a general (but also personal) orientation to this kind of knowledge and its usefulness. The format of a week- or longer-workshop sounds fine. And definitely the spirit of CCCS - not always so harmonious!!!
The info you ask for:

Visits -
I have not done an extended visit before, like a fellowship or something, but I have taught in other countries and of course made many shorter visits to places in US and Europe for intellectual exchanges. I don't know whether you want a systematic list of these. It is a very long list!! I might be able to abstract them from earlier cvs. But probably the best examples would be teaching 'Compact Courses' - a week or so long on national identity - in two German Universities - the Humbolt University in Berlin and the Cultural Studies Centre at Tubingen - both famous for this work. I also worked for a short while at Roskilde, an experimental university in Denmark, and I had a longish visit or two to work with Stanley Aronowitz at the Graduate Centre at City University New York. I have also spent some days at the European University at Fiesole, Italy examining students and giving talks. I was involved with the Erasmus cultural studies circle, a European wide network that involved visits to several European countries with groups of students. These are all from memory. Lee - if you want dates etc I will try and look them up.

No problem in principle in sending you passport copies or copies of certificates. I am not sure I can find all my certificates, but probably I could find my Cambridge Ph.D - which is my 'higher degree' Would that do?
I shall be away for a week from this Friday. But will reply to any reply of yours before I go. Sorry for occasional time-lags!
Excellent proposals Lee
Cheers
Richard


On 1 Jul 2008, at 03:17, Lee Yu-Hsuan wrote:
Dear Richard,

Recently, I talked with a senior scholar who is experienced and insightful in organising the events with respect to the inviting professor. We have exchanged some ideas in preparing your coming next year, which might be more productive than just some openly intellectual forums as suggested earlier.

First, we need you to stay basiclly in the southern part of Taiwan. That means you don't need to be like a celebrity traveling around Taiwan, receivng the greetings and PR every day. You might want to give some lectures in the universities, but the key task is a dialogue between your biography and this historical moment of TW.

Second, this arrangement is a serious consideration to reflect on the tensions between intellectual works and community works. By community I refer to a wider sense of locally embedded issues (agriculture, aborginal people, cultural policy, etc.), adult-education organisations, social movements, and institutionalised structures of political economy (e.g., local governments). Some advisers, those who dedicate their whole life to both intellectual and community works, are suggesting me to invite you to look at our local problems in the south. Once you and we can work together to examine some organisations and people's needs and problems, we may know how to let the questions lead our further discussions.
So, I, as a key facilitator, am not keen on making your visit as a star-like tour, but will let you and local org/people learn how to pose/answer some key questions as follows:
1. What is cultural studies anyway? (in the case of Taiwan, specifically for local communities)2. What can we learn from different visions and lessons between TW and UK, say, adult education, community work/education, social movements?
3. What are the blackholes of org/people in dedicating theirselves to local issues?
4. What are the strategies/tactics/ethos we should have?...............

If you are happy with this kind of arrangement, we will organise the event as early as possible as there are a lot of cases and resources worth mobilisation. As I am still apply for your funding from the university, I wonder if you might provide some photocopies of official certificates for reference, i.e., a graduation certificate, a passport photocopy. This procedure is needed for our government to examine the backgrounds of inviting scholars, including their labour rights, ID, etc. I am still thinking the way in which you can provide me these photocopies. Is the post available for you? Also, have you had been the inviting professor before? If yes, can you also give me specific information regarding this ? (I know it is a bit silly, but the university's staff is not in our realm. I am really upset over this requirement from the bureaucracy.) Anyway, my goal is clearer now. Your trip should be the practice of cultural studies for the local instead of a replication of a common tendency of intellectual studies/PR events from above.
Kind regards,Yu-Hsuan Lee


From: blue95_7399@msn.comTo: richard.johnson61@btinternet.comSubject: RE: Selections and alternative sourcesDate: Fri, 6 Jun 2008 22:24:41 +0800

Yes, Richard, I am thinking to get all those items of WPCS. And I actually have an idea and wonder whether it is doable. Shall we try to replay kind of WPCS' spirit in Taiwan during your fieldtrip? Is there any form you prefer to organize this one-month event? In addtion to some seminars concerning different topics, I think that an innovative way to have a workshop-like discussion might let people think back those days of CCCS. So, I wonder that a one-week or 5-day workshop might be a way in mobilising all scholars and students throughout Taiwan?

Kind regards,Yu-Hsuan Lee



From: richard.johnson61@btinternet.comTo: blue95_7399@msn.comSubject: Selections and alternative sources Date: Fri, 6 Jun 2008 13:18:08 +0100
Lee, the reference is not to the original WPCS but to a recently published selection from WPCS and Stencilled Papers which is in two volumes and has recently been published by Routledge. So, though expensive, it should be possible for your library to buy them. The original CCCS WPCS are rare items indeed - you are lucky to have any! I suggested this because i thought it would be easier! I do have all the original WPCS volumes and also the reprinted two vol selection.
However, several items have also been published elsewhere - thus:
1.What is Cultural Studies anyway? is reprinted in a number of different places e.g. in the US journal Social Text (n part) and in a reader edited by Ann Gray and David Morely (in full I think).
2.'Really Useful Knowledge' is also in the volume edited by myself, John Clarke and Chas Critcher, Working-Class Culture: Studies in History and Theory , one of the original Hutchinson volumes, about 1979 from memory. See my bibliog again. Can you get the Making Histories volume, again on the the original Hutchinson volumes? The p[iece on Marx is important to see the influence of Marxism on method as well as on my view of capital etc.
I am assuming people will also have access to The Practice of Cultural Studies where some of the arguments in What is CS Anyway? have been further developed, especially the circuit model and its relation to method. So you could use that chapter instead.
I've got the Chen, Asian Cultural Studies vol now - it looks very interesting.
Very best
Richard

On 4 Jun 2008, at 17:16, Lee Yu-Hsuan wrote:
Dear Richard, Thanks. It is a pity that libraries in Taiwan do not have CCCS Selected Working Papers. I will check if the library can buy it. Do you have the copies of them? I had 1, 3, and 4.
Kind regards,Yu-Hsuan Lee


From: richard.johnson61@btinternet.comTo: blue95_7399@msn.comSubject: Re: Third legs and reading groupsDate: Wed, 4 Jun 2008 15:23:47 +0100
Dear Lee,
Here are my suggestions. Bearing in mind availability too. You should be able to find the full references in my cv bibliography.
No particular order.
1. 'What is Cultural Studies Anyway?' This has also recently been reprinted in the Routledge CCCS archive volumes Ann Gray et al., (eds) CCCS Selected Working Papers 2 Volumes Vol 1. London: Routledge 2007 (Useful if your library had these volumes for my visit).
2. 'Really Useful Knowledge' Radical Education and Working-Class Culture 1790-1848' This is also in Vol 1 of the Routledge collection.
3. 'Reading for the Best Marx: History-Writing and Historical Abstraction' in Making Histories
4. 'Post-Hegemony? I don't Think So' TCS Vol 24, No3.
5."Washington's Favourite' in Steinberg and Johnson, Blairism and the War of Persuasion.
Let me know if any of these are not available and I can suggest others.
Warm wishes
Richard